Customer Reviews for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
This smudge-resistant, smear-resistant mascara magnifies lashes with a natural effect! Professional Mascara's pro-glide brush finds lashes you didn't know you had, for a great look without the usual clumps or globs.
Average Customer Rating:
(63 Reviews) 61
Rating Snapshot (63 reviews)
5 stars
17
4 stars
7
3 stars
5
2 stars
13
1 star
21
26 out of 63(41%)customers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Review 1 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Bring back the old formula, please!!
,April 30, 2013
By Obnrse
"I used the old formula in this color case in the Brown/black color for a gaziliion years and loved it!! Now it's been changed and is no way as good as the old one. It's watery and does not hold up as well as the old formula. Why mess with perfection?"
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.
Review 2 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
What happened to my color?
,April 17, 2013
By Peachgirl64
"I have used this mascara for years in the brown black color - I can't seem to find it anywhere! Please tell me you have not discontinued that color!! Already gave up on eyeliner and powder because NEW formulas were awful."
6 of 6 people found this review helpful.
Review 3 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
CAP BREAKS! Please FIX
,February 12, 2013
By ch12801
from Glens Falls, NY
"I love this mascara but purchased 3 different times & the cap keeps cracking when you close product forcing me to super glue the cap so I don't waste the product. I thought it was me but I found other reviews on web about same thing. BAD DESIGN"
Review 4 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Viva La Marathon
,December 1, 2012
By Blackcat
from Marlton, NJ
"Why did cover girl delete the “marathon” it was the best waterproof mascara on the market. I tried the “all in one”, but it's not even a close second. The mind boggles as to why they would delete a superior product that no one could compete with."
8 of 8 people found this review helpful.
Review 5 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
I tried this one too
,June 3, 2012
By makeuppro
from Las Vegas, NV
"I've been trying to find something to replace Marathon Mascara for 3 years. This product may be water resistant, but it is not truly waterproof. It wore off too easy & smudged under my eyes like the rest. Would love to see you bring Marathon back!!!"
9 of 11 people found this review helpful.
Review 6 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Doesn't Come Close
,February 5, 2012
By KSako
from Orange County, CA
"Doesn't hold a candle to Marathon mascara. Flakes, runs and doesn't hold a curl. More money wasted on trying to find something to replace Marathon. I'm athletic and outdoorsy, so I really enjoyed Marathon's staying power. PLEASE bring it back!"
14 of 16 people found this review helpful.
Review 7 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Thumbs down
,January 24, 2012
By Elisha
"I can't believe this is the substitute for Marathon. This flaked so badly, ran if I came near water and made my lashes stick straight. More money wasted. Please bring back Marathon. I'll pay triple for it lol, probably more. Petition maybe ; )"
9 of 12 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, January 26, 2012
I am sorry you are missing your Marathon. We are here to help. Give us a call so we can help you find a mascara that will work for you.
Review 8 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Not Waterproof
,January 23, 2012
By Summer621
from Youngstown, OH
"This was okay for the price. I have tried all the Cover Girl "waterproof" mascaras, and none of them can come close to Marathon. Cover Girl needs to bring it back!"
6 of 9 people found this review helpful.
Review 9 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
OK for the price...
,January 14, 2012
By bones697
from Washington, DC
"I got this for $5.50 at Shoppers, and it's pretty good, but if it were more expensive, I would be disappointed."
4 of 9 people found this review helpful.
Review 10 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Dissapointing
,September 20, 2011
By Weepy
from Topeka, KS
"Marathon Waterproof was the ONLY one that ever worked well for me, & it would seem that others feel the same. I keep trying others with no success. I have oily eyelids, & watery eyes. This one left flakes and smears. Please bring back what we want!"
26 of 34 people found this review helpful.
Review 11 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Excellent purchase
,September 18, 2011
By Lilly26
"I have straight Asian eyelashes, and this is the only mascara that really works for me. It clumps a little, so what I do is I blink slightly while applying. This mascara is definitely waterproof, and I love it! It definitely keeps my eyelashes curled"
8 of 15 people found this review helpful.
Review 12 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Bring Back Marathon Mascara PLEASE!!!!
,September 9, 2011
By Lyn3333
from Mankato, MN
"I wore Marathon Mascara since my teens and it never flaked off or gave me black rings under my eyes like this CG product does. I am so disappointed that Cover Girl will not return Marathon Mascara back to the shelves after reading all the requests!"
11 of 18 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, September 13, 2011
I am sorry you are missing the Marathon. Give us a call at 1-800-426-8374 so we can ask you a few questions and recommend a mascara that will work great for you.
Review 13 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
At last!
,August 17, 2011
By geogirl
from Ventura, California
"After my favorite mascara was discontinued (L'Oreal), I tried many brands (incl. other CG products) until I found Pro All-in-One. It separates and defines fine lashes, and the Waterproof version really holds the curl and lasts all day. Thank you CG!"
8 of 16 people found this review helpful.
Review 14 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
NOT SO GOOD.....
,August 12, 2011
By JuliaK
from Colorado Springs, Colorado
"Pros: very waterproof, cleanser-proof, cry-proof, anything-proof.
Cons: Will not get the heck off my eyelashes, is heavy, thick, and clumpy, and does not coat my lashes one-by-one, as Covergirl says all their mascaras will."
Cons: Will not get the heck off my eyelashes, is heavy, thick, and clumpy, and does not coat my lashes one-by-one, as Covergirl says all their mascaras will."
10 of 17 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, August 16, 2011
We are glad you are enjoying the Pros of the product. I am sorry you are having a difficult time removing the mascara. You may want to try our Cover Girl Clean Makeup Remover for Eye and Lips.
Review 15 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
not waterproof
,August 1, 2011
By watergirl
from Jackson, Wyoming
"Please bring back marathon mascara. I have tried all your mascaras & the marathon mascara was the only one that was truly waterproof. The professional all-in-one is fine for a non-swimmer & crier. CG marathon mascara is now going on ebay for $75."
10 of 15 people found this review helpful.
Review 16 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
BRING BACK MARATHON
,July 27, 2011
By Kknapp
from Chestertown MD
"THIS IS A HORRIBLE REPLACEMENT FOR MARATHON......I HAVE USED MARATHON SINCE I WAS A TEEN....43 NOW... WHOMEVER THOUGHT THAT THIS WAS EVEN A CLOSE REPLACEMENT HAS NEVER WORN MASCARA!!!!! UGGGHHHH."
9 of 14 people found this review helpful.
Review 17 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
TOO waterproof!
,June 27, 2011
By hab1
from Indianapolis, IN
"This is my first time buying this product....and last! I don't think I'll even finish it. It's way TOO waterproof, and soap-proof, and eyemake remover-proof. I can't get the stuff off of my eyelashes!!! HELP!!!"
6 of 9 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, June 29, 2011
I am here to help. I am sorry you are having a difficult time removing the mascara. I use the Cover Girl Clean Makeup Remover for Eye and Lips and it works great. Give this a try and let us know how it works for you.
Review 18 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
FAIL unfortunately
,May 17, 2011
By heathermrm
from Twin Cities, MN
"Potential replacement for Marathon? NOT! As w/ many women on big makeup review site = FAIL! I've used Marathon since high school (I'm now 45). Tried most CG h2o-proof mascaras as replacements = nope! Very sad CG has lost a customer of 30 years."
13 of 18 people found this review helpful.
Review 19 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Bring Back Marathon Mascara---NOTHING is as good
,May 9, 2011
By 4949
from new york ny
"Tied every mascara available before it was discontinued, every mascara available since (including all Cover Girl so called replacements nothing compares}. They all flake. clump, lump and none can hold a curl like Marathon. U lost a customer for good"
6 of 8 people found this review helpful.
Review 20 for Professional All-in-One Waterproof Mascara
Best Mascara
,May 7, 2011
By Jenni4
from Pasadena, TX
"I've tried alot of different mascaras, but this one is my favorite. I have fairly skimpy lashes with no natural curl, so i have to curl them daily. This waterproof formula helps hold the curl, and resists clumping and smuging. Love it in Very Black"
2 of 3 people found this review helpful.