Customer Reviews for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
The pencil gives you control and versatility. Want a precise line? It glides on easily. Want to soften a bit? There's a soft smudger tip. Best of all? No sharpening necessary, it's got a specially designed self-sharpener inside. So you always get the point� perfectly.
Average Customer Rating:
(241 Reviews) 240
Rating Snapshot (241 reviews)
5 stars
97
4 stars
37
3 stars
28
2 stars
30
1 star
49
148 out of 241(61%)customers would recommend this product to a friend.
Customer Reviews for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Review 1 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Great Product, Terrible Packaging
,January 24, 2012
By Kimlw
from Glassboro, New Jersey
"The eyeliner goes on wonderfully, but the plastic tube and cap begin to crack and fall apart within the first few uses. The cap cracks so badly that I can no longer use it. This problem is so bad that I will cannot continue to use this product."
2 of 3 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, January 31, 2012
I am reporting this to our packaging division. This is not what we would expect from this package. Give us a call at 1-800-426-8374 so we can get it replaced for you.
Review 2 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
BRING BACK OUTLAST SMOOTHWEAR ALL-DAY EYELINER!!!!
,January 22, 2012
By ShyStar
from Chicago, IL
"I tried the Perfect Point Plus eyeliner because CoverGirl said that it was a great replacement for the discontinued eye liner that I've worn for years. Well, its not! After an hour, this eyeliner is a smudging mess."
3 of 5 people found this review helpful.
Review 3 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Losing Faith in Covergirl
,January 16, 2012
By SG8753
from Tallahassee, FL
"I used to love this product, but I haven't been able to find it in black or charcoal at the WalMart near me for about a year now. I tried grey khaki as a replacement, and it broke the first time I used it. Certainly not what I expect from Covergirl."
3 of 5 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, January 19, 2012
Please keep the faith! I can assure you we are still making the Black and Charcoal colors. Ask the WalMart manager if they can get these colors in for you. I am sorry your last purchase broke. Please give us a call at 1-800-426-8374 so we can help.
Review 4 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Not Quite
,January 4, 2012
By MNPM
from Lexington, KY
"I enjoyed the precise point of this liner so much that I bought 3 AND THEN... I used it 1 time a day for 5 days and now it won't advance anymore. I like a natural look so I didn't use much.
I can't believe there's not more than 1/2" of liner."
5 of 11 people found this review helpful.
Review 5 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
GREAT CLASSIC! Now Bring BACK Marathon Mascara
,December 30, 2011
By HeartsFaith
from Warren, MI
"I've been using this for MANY years & it goes on easily, can be smudged for smoky eye look or defined for dramatic look. STAYS put & great color choices! This was great w/CG MARATHON WP mascara ANOTHER classic & bad choice to discontinue that formula"
4 of 9 people found this review helpful.
Review 6 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
The quality isn't what it used to be.
,December 28, 2011
By tsmithrn
from Columbia, MO
"The tip of the last three pencils I've purchased break-off way too easily. I am careful to not make the point too long, but it doesn't seem to matter; I end up throwing half of the pencil away, one small chunk at a time."
8 of 12 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, January 4, 2012
CoverGirl is all about great quality. I am sorry you had an issue with your last few pencils. Please give us a call so we can get some additional details and help you with this.
Review 7 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Love it!
,December 3, 2011
By tinydancermom
from Jax, FL
"Bought this for my daughter's dance make-up bag and it was so easy to apply on her that I went and bought some for me too! Glides on easily, I do have to apply it a few times on her to get that stage ready look but easier than regular eye pencils!"
8 of 15 people found this review helpful.
Review 8 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
LOVE IT!!!!
,October 19, 2011
By Beth01
from Orlando, FL
"I used this product for shows and I loved it. It is the only eyeliner i use!"
8 of 18 people found this review helpful.
Review 9 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Won't Buy Again
,October 12, 2011
By Mrsedge
from Boise, ID
"I bought this in the Black Onyx and Plum Velvet. I tried to use the purple and I have to go over my eyes for several minutes to get even a hint of line. I was so disgusted that I haven't even bothered to open the black."
11 of 22 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, October 18, 2011
If you are looking for something that will give you eye more definition, we can help. Give us a call so we can ask you a few questions and recommend a product that will give you the look you want. You can reach us at 1-800-426-8374.
Review 10 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Wonderful!
,September 26, 2011
By Fefe
from London, England
"I used to use a Sephora eyeliner, but it kept coming off. I finally used this one in charcoal, and I LOVED how it stayed on! It was also really easy to use. It went on easy, and came off easy!!! Way to go cover girl!"
12 of 19 people found this review helpful.
Review 11 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
I love this product!
,September 24, 2011
By Malia
from Longmont, Co
"I use the Espresso eyeliner which brings out the warmth in my skin. I love that I can draw precise lines and don't have to worry about sharpening it. I've never used liquid eyeliner to compare it to but I really like it and will keep using it daily!"
7 of 13 people found this review helpful.
Review 12 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Horrible product
,September 17, 2011
By jwen
from St Cloud, MN
"I've purchased 2 of these in the charcoal, which isn't nearly as harsh as black. The color is great, however, they were bought at 2 separate times and both pencils keep breaking. Even without twisting them up very far, they break every use."
6 of 13 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, September 20, 2011
Glad to hear the color is great! I am sorry that the tip is breaking. We would like to help you with this and get it reported. Please give us a call at 1-800-426-8374.
Review 13 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
no
,August 29, 2011
By angelataco
"bad smuged so easly it was crazy i looked so tyred when the eye liner smugged down mu lower lash line so bad"
8 of 19 people found this review helpful.
Review 14 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Not Quite Up CG's Usual Standard
,August 25, 2011
By AliceInWinderland90
from San Diego, CA
"The liner goes on easily enough, but within just a few hours- 2 at most- the color has basically melted down my cheeks and into the creases of my upper lids."
7 of 11 people found this review helpful.
Review 15 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Dissatisfied!
,August 9, 2011
By Lolly24
from Charlotte, NC
"I tried this eyeliner in plum and it barely showed up! I had to go over it a million times just to get some color on my eyes and then it was almost completely gone in a couple hours. I really wouldn't buy this product again or try it any other color."
9 of 11 people found this review helpful.
Response from CoverGirl:By Jenny, CoverGirl Team, August 11, 2011
We offer other eyeliners that will give you the look you want. Give us a call at 1-800-426-8374 so we can ask you a few questions and make a suggestion that will work great for you!
Review 16 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Grey Khaki- a unique color!
,August 2, 2011
By Margerydoll
from Covington, VA
"No problems using this, does not break, can get a thin line,only smudges when I deliberately smudge it. Was using Line Stylist , but this is better. If it breaks, then maybe you are pushing down too hard. Not good for your eyes or the liner."
7 of 11 people found this review helpful.
Review 17 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Not good for oily skin!
,July 5, 2011
By MommaB
from Des Moines, IA
"I used the Outlast eyeliner for over a year and loved it. I tried this since Outlast was discontinued and dislike it immensely. It smudges terribly, and by about 11:00 I have raccoon eyes. It also breaks off every time I try to use it. Won't buy!"
6 of 10 people found this review helpful.
Review 18 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
My use for this pruduct: Pros and Cons
,July 3, 2011
By rosieblushforever
from Baltimore, MD
"I use this product to tightline my eyes.
Pros: -creates volume to my eye
-works beautifully
-never have to sharpen another eyeliner pencil
-longlasting [if you don't touch your eyes]
Cons: -smudges easily"
Pros: -creates volume to my eye
-works beautifully
-never have to sharpen another eyeliner pencil
-longlasting [if you don't touch your eyes]
Cons: -smudges easily"
5 of 6 people found this review helpful.
Review 19 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Would not recommend
,May 29, 2011
By musicismylife
from Normal, IL
"This eyeliner smudged WAY too much and would come off my my third hour class, and it would be all the way down my eye and all over my eyelid. And, once you get to the end, it breaks. I would not recommend this, even though I love the self sharpening."
3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
Review 20 for Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
No thanks.
,May 26, 2011
By kutdo
from irvine, ca
"I had used this eyeliner before,but switched to another for some time. I had a coupon and bought this again. Now I remember why I switched... it smears and smudges so easily. Always reapplying in just a matter of an hour.. not cool."
1 of 1 people found this review helpful.